The Court of Appeal in Abuja has reserved judgment in two appeals filed by the Socio-Economic Rights and Accountability Project (SERAP) and its Deputy Director, Kolawole Oluwadare, challenging a N100 million defamation judgment involving two officers of the Department of State Services (DSS).
A three-member panel led by Justice Danlami Senchi reserved judgment after hearing arguments from the parties and their legal representatives. The court said the date for delivering its decision would be communicated to those involved.
The appeals, registered as CA/ABJ/CV/1114/2026 and CA/ABJ/CV/1105/2026, seek to overturn the judgment of the High Court of the Federal Capital Territory (FCT), which found SERAP and Oluwadare liable for defaming two DSS operatives.
The appellants are challenging the lower court’s findings and the financial award made in favour of the officers.
During the proceedings, counsel representing the appellants urged the appellate court to set aside the judgment. However, the lawyers representing the DSS officers maintained that the lower court’s decision was justified and asked the panel to dismiss the appeals.
In one of the related proceedings, the court also granted an application for additional time to regularise the appellant’s legal processes after the respondents raised no objection.
Why SERAP is challenging the judgment
SERAP’s appeal centres on whether the two DSS officers were sufficiently identified in the publications that formed the basis of their defamation claim.
The organisation argued that the officers were not mentioned by their names, ranks, official positions or photographs. It maintained that the physical descriptions contained in the publications were too general to establish that the statements referred specifically to the two claimants.
SERAP also questioned the trial court’s reliance on its own observation of the officers’ physical appearances when determining whether they had been identified.
According to the organisation, the court should have required independent evidence establishing that readers of the publications understood the descriptions to refer to the particular officers.
The appellants further disputed the evidence presented concerning alleged psychological injury, professional damage and the widespread circulation of the publications.
SERAP maintains that its comments concerned the conduct of security personnel who visited its Abuja office and were made in the context of public-interest reporting and accountability.
It also argued that the trial court did not properly evaluate its legal defences, including justification, qualified privilege and the constitutional protection of freedom of expression under Section 39(1) of the 1999 Constitution, as amended.
The organisation is asking the Court of Appeal to overturn the damages award and the directive requiring it to issue public apologies.
How the N100m dispute started
The legal battle can be traced to September 9, 2024, when SERAP raised an alarm over the presence of DSS operatives at its Abuja office.
The organisation alleged that security officials had unlawfully occupied its premises and were demanding to meet its directors. It called on President Bola Tinubu to intervene, describing the incident as an act of intimidation against its staff and human rights work.
The DSS rejected that account the following day.
The security agency said two of its unarmed operatives had been assigned to visit SERAP’s office as part of a routine investigation. It maintained that the visit was a legitimate official enquiry and should not have been characterised as an invasion or harassment.
The disagreement over the circumstances of that visit subsequently developed into a defamation dispute.
What the High Court decided
Two DSS officers, Sarah John and Gabriel Ogundele, later instituted a defamation action against SERAP and its Deputy Director, Kolawole Oluwadare.
In a judgment delivered on May 5, 2026, Justice Yusuf Halilu of the FCT High Court awarded N100 million in damages to the claimants.
The court also directed the defendants to publish public apologies through specified national newspapers, television stations and SERAP’s online platforms.
An additional N1 million was awarded as litigation costs, while the judgment provided for 10 per cent annual post-judgment interest until the judgment debt is fully paid.
SERAP rejected the decision and announced that it would challenge the ruling through the appellate process.
What happens next?
With arguments now concluded in both appeals, attention has shifted to the Court of Appeal’s forthcoming decision.
The appellate court will have to determine whether the trial court correctly applied the principles of defamation, properly assessed the evidence of identification and injury, and adequately considered the constitutional and legal defences raised by the appellants.
Until judgment is delivered, the N100 million damages award and the related orders remain subject to the outcome of the appeals and any applicable court orders.
The decision is expected to attract attention from civil society organisations, human rights advocates and legal practitioners, particularly because of the questions it raises about defamation law, public-interest reporting and freedom of expression in Nigeria.
















